feat(main-loop): digest response protocol — actionable digests, reply verbs, closure metrics

Session: sidechat/main-loop-protocol
2026-10-05 00:48:38 +00:00
parent 664b4da952
commit 86f0082ffc
3 changed files with 461 additions and 22 deletions
@@ -4,8 +4,9 @@ response-harvester.py — Fleet agent readback and response harvesting daemon.

 Monitors Chromebox agents (muse, pip, 646, opm), harvests incoming messages from
 Main Chat and registered sidechats, maintains persistent watermarks, appends to
-chat-history.jsonl, resolves pending follow-ups, and records [RESULT] completions
-in job-log.jsonl.
+chat-history.jsonl, resolves pending follow-ups (verb-aware: [ACK|CLAIM] ->
+acknowledged, [RESULT|DECLINE|NO-ACTION] -> resolved, outcome recorded), and
+records [RESULT] completions in job-log.jsonl.

 Features:
 - Direct CDP over host veth interfaces (fast, no sudo needed).
@@ -83,6 +84,20 @@ def iter_result_markers(text):
        yield m.group(1).strip(), m.group(2).strip()


+# Verb markers for the digest response protocol:
+# [ACK|CLAIM|RESULT|DECLINE|NO-ACTION <job_id>].
+# ACK/CLAIM acknowledge a digest (nudge-suppressed, NOT closed);
+# RESULT/DECLINE/NO-ACTION close the digest. Every verb match records
+# outcome=<verb> on the followup record.
+VERB_RE = re.compile(r"\[(ACK|CLAIM|RESULT|DECLINE|NO-ACTION)\s+([A-Za-z0-9_-]+)\]")
+
+
+def iter_verb_markers(text):
+    """Yield (verb, job_id) for every [VERB <job_id>] marker in text."""
+    for m in VERB_RE.finditer(text or ""):
+        yield m.group(1), m.group(2).strip()
+
+

 def utcnow():
    return datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat()
@@ -366,7 +381,8 @@ def harvest_main_feed(cdp, agent, watermarks, followups, dry_run=False):

        if author == "assistant":
            markers = list(iter_result_markers(text))
-            if markers:
+            verbs = list(iter_verb_markers(text))
+            if markers or verbs:
                for job_id, result_text in markers:
                    is_fail = is_fail_result(result_text)
                    job_results += 1
@@ -385,7 +401,12 @@ def harvest_main_feed(cdp, agent, watermarks, followups, dry_run=False):
                        append_jsonl(JOB_LOG, job_record)
                        trigger_chain_next(job_id, result_text, success=not is_fail)
                    clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, "main", mid, text,
-                                             dry_run, job_id=job_id)
+                                             dry_run, job_id=job_id, verb="RESULT")
+                for verb, job_id in verbs:
+                    if verb == "RESULT":
+                        continue  # resolved via the result-marker path above
+                    clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, "main", mid, text,
+                                             dry_run, job_id=job_id, verb=verb)
            else:
                clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, "main", mid, text, dry_run)

@@ -487,7 +508,8 @@ def harvest_agent_thread(cdp, agent, thread_info, watermarks, followups, dry_run

        if author == "assistant":
            markers = list(iter_result_markers(text))
-            if markers:
+            verbs = list(iter_verb_markers(text))
+            if markers or verbs:
                for job_id, result_text in markers:
                    is_fail = is_fail_result(result_text)
                    job_results += 1
@@ -507,7 +529,12 @@ def harvest_agent_thread(cdp, agent, thread_info, watermarks, followups, dry_run
                        # Trigger pipeline chaining or next job if configured
                        trigger_chain_next(job_id, result_text, success=not is_fail)
                    clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, thread_id, mid, text,
-                                             dry_run, job_id=job_id)
+                                             dry_run, job_id=job_id, verb="RESULT")
+                for verb, job_id in verbs:
+                    if verb == "RESULT":
+                        continue  # resolved via the result-marker path above
+                    clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, thread_id, mid, text,
+                                             dry_run, job_id=job_id, verb=verb)
            else:
                clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, thread_id, mid, text, dry_run)

@@ -611,7 +638,7 @@ def trigger_chain_next(job_id, result_text, success=True):


 def clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, thread_id, mid, text, dry_run=False,
-                             job_id=None):
+                             job_id=None, verb=None):
    """Resolve follow-up records if an assistant message is detected in the thread.

    Matches on thread identity (thread_uuid or target='main') OR on job_id
@@ -619,13 +646,27 @@ def clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, thread_id, mid, text, dry_run=Fal
    thread_uuid or target, fixing ghost followups with null thread_uuid.
    Also matches a main-chat reply when the sweeper recorded
    final_nudge_target='main' (final nudge routed to main chat).
+
+    When verb is given ([ACK|CLAIM|RESULT|DECLINE|NO-ACTION <job_id>]),
+    matching is job_id-scoped for non-RESULT verbs (a verb marker names the
+    digest it answers, so it must not touch unrelated pending followups that
+    merely share the thread); RESULT keeps the historical thread-or-job
+    matching. Every verb match records outcome=<verb>. ACK/CLAIM set status
+    'acknowledged' (nudge-suppressed, NOT closed) instead of 'resolved', and
+    also match already-'acknowledged' records so an ACK -> RESULT lifecycle
+    closes correctly.
    """
    if not followups:
        return

    modified = False
    for f_id, f_rec in followups.items():
-        if f_rec.get("status") != "pending":
+        # Verb replies can follow an ACK (ACK -> RESULT lifecycle), so verbs
+        # also match 'acknowledged' records; plain replies only match pending.
+        if verb:
+            if f_rec.get("status") not in ("pending", "acknowledged"):
+                continue
+        elif f_rec.get("status") != "pending":
            continue
        if f_rec.get("recipient") != agent:
            continue
@@ -642,17 +683,33 @@ def clear_matching_followups(followups, agent, thread_id, mid, text, dry_run=Fal
            # sidechat.
            match_thread = True

-        # Match by job_id (from [RESULT <job_id>]) -- works regardless of
-        # thread_uuid or target. This is an ADDITIONAL path, not a replacement.
+        # Match by job_id (from [RESULT <job_id>] or [VERB <job_id>]) --
+        # works regardless of thread_uuid or target. This is an ADDITIONAL
+        # path, not a replacement.
        match_job = False
        if job_id and f_rec.get("job_id") and f_rec.get("job_id") == job_id:
            match_job = True

+        # Non-RESULT verbs are job-scoped: they must not acknowledge/resolve
+        # unrelated pending followups that merely share the thread. RESULT
+        # keeps the historical thread-or-job matching.
+        if verb and verb != "RESULT" and not match_job:
+            continue
+
        if match_thread or match_job:
-            f_rec["status"] = "resolved"
-            f_rec["resolved_at"] = utcnow()
-            f_rec["resolved_by_mid"] = mid
-            f_rec["resolved_snippet"] = text[:150]
+            if verb:
+                f_rec["outcome"] = verb
+            if verb in ("ACK", "CLAIM"):
+                # Acknowledged: sweeper nudges stop (status != pending), but
+                # the digest is NOT closed until a closing verb arrives.
+                f_rec["status"] = "acknowledged"
+                f_rec["acknowledged_at"] = utcnow()
+                f_rec["acknowledged_by_mid"] = mid
+            else:
+                f_rec["status"] = "resolved"
+                f_rec["resolved_at"] = utcnow()
+                f_rec["resolved_by_mid"] = mid
+                f_rec["resolved_snippet"] = text[:150]
            modified = True

    if modified and not dry_run:
@@ -37,6 +37,7 @@ import os
 import re
 import subprocess
 import sys
+import time
 from contextlib import contextmanager
 from datetime import datetime, timezone

@@ -44,11 +45,20 @@ BASE = "/home/super/Projects/NetVM"
 BIN = os.path.join(BASE, "bin")
 if BIN not in sys.path:
    sys.path.insert(0, BIN)
+
+# Deterministic per-agent jittered sleeps — de-correlates within-run
+# traffic across the shared egress IP (see rate_limiter.py).
+try:
+    from rate_limiter import effective_interval as _effective_interval
+    HAS_RATE_LIMITER = True
+except ImportError:
+    HAS_RATE_LIMITER = False
 BOX_CHAT = os.path.join(BIN, "box-chat.py")
 DM_PY = os.path.join(BIN, "dm.py")
 STATE_FILE = os.path.join(BASE, "self-main-loop-watermark.json")
 LOCK_FILE = os.path.join(BASE, "self-main-loop.lock")
 STATE_LOCK_FILE = os.path.join(BASE, "self-main-loop-state.lock")
+FOLLOWUPS_FILE = os.path.join(BASE, "followups.json")

 DEFAULT_AGENTS = ["muse", "pip", "646", "opm"]
 # Prompting sidechat per agent — mirrors box-ctl.py NOTIFY_SIDECHATS.
@@ -63,6 +73,7 @@ READ_LIMIT = 30
 READ_TIMEOUT = 120
 SEND_TIMEOUT = 180
 DIGEST_MAX = 600  # well under dm.py's 1000-char non-raw truncation
+INTER_NODE_SLEEP_BASE = 7.0  # s between per-agent passes; jittered per agent
 PREVIEW_MAX = 120

 # Word-boundary "operator" that does NOT match hyphenated identities like
@@ -239,10 +250,69 @@ def get_monitored_sidechats(agent):
    return monitored


+def classify_digest(digest):
+    """Return (actionable, urgent) for a composed digest.
+
+    Actionable = digest carries a (?) question or (!) operator-needed marker.
+    Urgent = digest carries the (!) marker.
+    """
+    urgent = " (!)" in digest
+    actionable = urgent or " (?)" in digest
+    return actionable, urgent
+
+
+def make_digest_id(agent):
+    """Stable digest ID: ml-<agent>-<YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS> (UTC)."""
+    ts = datetime.now(timezone.utc).strftime("%Y%m%d-%H%M%S")
+    return "ml-%s-%s" % (agent, ts)
+
+
+# In-band response-contract footer for ACTIONABLE digests. The verbs are matched
+# by response-harvester.py to resolve followups: ACK/CLAIM acknowledge (nudge
+# suppression), RESULT/DECLINE/NO-ACTION close. ~94 chars, well under budget.
+CONTRACT_FOOTER = ("Reply: [ACK id] seen | [CLAIM id] mine | "
+                   "[RESULT id] done | [DECLINE id] | [NO-ACTION id]")
+
+
 def send_prompt(sender, agent, sidechat, digest):
    """Post the digest to the agent's prompting sidechat.
-    Tries fast direct gateway send via muse_hybrid first, falling back to dm.py.
+
+    Actionable digests (carrying (?) or (!)) go via dm.py with --expect-reply
+    so the followup machinery tracks them; the digest gets a [JOB <id>] tag
+    which dm.py auto-extracts into the followup record. Informational digests
+    try the fast gateway first, falling back to dm.py without followup flags.
+
+    Returns (sent, detail, digest_id, actionable).
    """
+    actionable, urgent = classify_digest(digest)
+    digest_id = make_digest_id(agent) if actionable else None
+
+    if actionable:
+        # Embed [JOB id] for dm.py's job_id extraction -> followup record,
+        # and append the response-contract footer. Reserve space for both so
+        # the tagged digest stays within DIGEST_MAX and dm.py never truncates
+        # the footer (or the job id).
+        head = "[JOB %s]\n" % digest_id
+        room = DIGEST_MAX - len(head) - len(CONTRACT_FOOTER) - 1
+        body = digest if len(digest) <= room else digest[:room].rstrip()
+        tagged = head + body + "\n" + CONTRACT_FOOTER
+        timeout = 1800 if urgent else 3600
+        cmd = [sys.executable, DM_PY, "send",
+               "--agent", sender, "--to", agent, "--target", sidechat,
+               "--expect-reply", "--reply-timeout", str(timeout),
+               "--reply-nudges", "2", tagged]
+        try:
+            r = subprocess.run(cmd, capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=SEND_TIMEOUT)
+        except subprocess.TimeoutExpired:
+            return False, "dm.py send timed out after %ss" % SEND_TIMEOUT, digest_id, True
+        except OSError as e:
+            return False, "could not exec dm.py: %s" % e, digest_id, True
+        if r.returncode != 0:
+            tail = ((r.stderr or "") + (r.stdout or "")).strip()[-300:]
+            return False, "dm.py send failed rc=%d: %s" % (r.returncode, tail), digest_id, True
+        return True, "sent (dm.py, expect-reply)", digest_id, True
+
+    # Informational: fast gateway first, dm.py fallback without followup flags.
    target_uuid = sidechat
    try:
        import dm
@@ -257,7 +327,7 @@ def send_prompt(sender, agent, sidechat, digest):
            send_node = agent if agent in DEFAULT_AGENTS else sender
            res, err = muse_hybrid.send_message(send_node, digest, thread_id=target_uuid, wait=0)
            if res and not err:
-                return True, "sent (gateway)"
+                return True, "sent (gateway)", None, False
            log("Gateway send fallback for %s/%s due to: %s" % (agent, sidechat, err or res))
        except Exception as e:
            log("Gateway send exception for %s/%s: %s" % (agent, sidechat, e))
@@ -268,13 +338,13 @@ def send_prompt(sender, agent, sidechat, digest):
    try:
        r = subprocess.run(cmd, capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=SEND_TIMEOUT)
    except subprocess.TimeoutExpired:
-        return False, "dm.py send timed out after %ss" % SEND_TIMEOUT
+        return False, "dm.py send timed out after %ss" % SEND_TIMEOUT, None, False
    except OSError as e:
-        return False, "could not exec dm.py: %s" % e
+        return False, "could not exec dm.py: %s" % e, None, False
    if r.returncode != 0:
        tail = ((r.stderr or "") + (r.stdout or "")).strip()[-300:]
-        return False, "dm.py send failed rc=%d: %s" % (r.returncode, tail)
-    return True, "sent (dm.py)"
+        return False, "dm.py send failed rc=%d: %s" % (r.returncode, tail), None, False
+    return True, "sent (dm.py)", None, False


 def check_sidechats(agent, cfg, wm, threads_meta):
@@ -472,7 +542,17 @@ def do_check(only_agent=None):

    import muse_hybrid

+    first_agent = True
    for agent in agents:
+        if not first_agent:
+            # Stagger per-node passes: timer staggering doesn't help within
+            # a run. Deterministic per-agent jitter keeps runs reproducible
+            # while drifting each node's phase apart.
+            sleep_s = (INTER_NODE_SLEEP_BASE * _effective_interval(agent, 1.0)
+                     if HAS_RATE_LIMITER else INTER_NODE_SLEEP_BASE)
+            log("%s: inter-node sleep %.1fs" % (agent, sleep_s))
+            time.sleep(sleep_s)
+        first_agent = False
        if not enabled.get(agent, True):
            results[agent] = {"ok": True, "new": 0, "disabled": True}
            continue
@@ -519,9 +599,12 @@ def do_check(only_agent=None):
            errors += 1
            continue

-        sent, detail = send_prompt(cfg["sender"], agent, sidechat, digest)
+        sent, detail, digest_id, actionable = send_prompt(cfg["sender"], agent, sidechat, digest)
        if sent:
            prompted += 1
+            if digest_id:
+                wm["last_digest_id"] = digest_id
+            wm["last_digest_actionable"] = actionable
            log("%s: prompted %s with %d new (%s)" % (agent, sidechat, total_new, detail))
            results[agent] = {"ok": True, "new": total_new, "prompted": sidechat, "detail": detail}
        else:
@@ -571,6 +654,91 @@ def _set_enabled(agent, value):
    return {"ok": True, "enabled": {a: enabled.get(a, True) for a in targets}}


+# Digest protocol job-id prefix: actionable main-loop digests embed
+# [JOB ml-<agent>-<YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS>]. Informational digests create no
+# followup at all, so every ml- followup is actionable by construction
+# and informational digests are excluded from all rates.
+DIGEST_JOB_PREFIX = "ml-"
+# Reply verbs that acknowledge without closing (nudge-suppressed).
+ACK_VERBS = {"ACK", "CLAIM"}
+# Reply verbs that close the digest.
+CLOSE_VERBS = {"RESULT", "DECLINE", "NO-ACTION"}
+
+
+def _followup_job_id(rec):
+    tags = rec.get("tags") or {}
+    return tags.get("job_id") or rec.get("job_id") or ""
+
+
+def _followup_is_stale(rec, now):
+    if rec.get("status") == "escalated":
+        return True
+    if rec.get("status") == "pending":
+        try:
+            dl = datetime.fromisoformat(
+                (rec.get("deadline") or "").replace("Z", "+00:00"))
+            return dl < now
+        except (ValueError, TypeError):
+            return False
+    return False
+
+
+def digest_health():
+    """Digest loop-closure metrics from followups.json.
+
+    Counts only actionable digests (job_id starting with 'ml-').
+    Reads the existing followups.json - no new state file, keeping
+    self-main-loop-watermark.json as the single status source.
+    """
+    now = datetime.now(timezone.utc)
+    health = {"delivered": 0, "acked": 0, "closed": 0, "stale": 0,
+              "closure_rate": None, "by_agent": {}}
+    try:
+        with open(FOLLOWUPS_FILE) as f:
+            data = json.load(f)
+    except (FileNotFoundError, json.JSONDecodeError, ValueError):
+        return health
+    records = data.values() if isinstance(data, dict) else data
+
+    for rec in records:
+        if not isinstance(rec, dict):
+            continue
+        job_id = _followup_job_id(rec)
+        if not job_id.startswith(DIGEST_JOB_PREFIX):
+            continue  # not a main-loop digest: excluded from all rates
+        agent = rec.get("recipient") or "?"
+        per = health["by_agent"].setdefault(
+            agent, {"delivered": 0, "acked": 0, "closed": 0, "stale": 0})
+
+        health["delivered"] += 1
+        per["delivered"] += 1
+
+        outcome = (rec.get("outcome") or "").upper()
+        status = rec.get("status") or ""
+        is_acked = status == "acknowledged" or outcome in ACK_VERBS
+        # resolved counts as closed unless the outcome was only an ACK/CLAIM
+        # (legacy pre-protocol resolutions have no outcome field).
+        is_closed = status == "resolved" and outcome not in ACK_VERBS
+
+        if is_acked:
+            health["acked"] += 1
+            per["acked"] += 1
+        if is_closed:
+            health["closed"] += 1
+            per["closed"] += 1
+        if _followup_is_stale(rec, now):
+            health["stale"] += 1
+            per["stale"] += 1
+
+    if health["delivered"]:
+        health["closure_rate"] = round(
+            health["closed"] / health["delivered"], 4)
+    for per in health["by_agent"].values():
+        per["closure_rate"] = (round(per["closed"] / per["delivered"], 4)
+                               if per["delivered"] else None)
+    return health
+
+
 def do_status():
    st = load_state()
    cfg = get_config(st)
@@ -580,7 +748,8 @@ def do_status():
            "enabled": cfg.get("enabled") or {},
            "watermark": agents_state,
            "last_run": st.get("last_run"),
-            "last_result": st.get("last_result")}
+            "last_result": st.get("last_result"),
+            "digest_health": digest_health()}


 def main(argv):
@@ -0,0 +1,213 @@
+# Digest Protocol Runbook
+
+How the main loop sends digests and how agents close them.
+
+**Status:** spec (2026-10-04). Implemented in `self_main_loop.py` + `response-harvester.py`;
+no new machinery — the protocol wires digests into the existing `dm.py --expect-reply`
+/ `followups.json` / harvester response path.
+
+---
+
+## 1. Why this protocol exists
+
+Main-loop digests (`[main-loop] N new in <agent> main chat: ...`) were being sent
+with no response contract: no stable ID, no declared timeout, no nudge/escalation
+policy, and no way to distinguish "seen and closed" from "ignored". Across 43
+digests there were zero RESULT replies and zero measurable outcomes — not because
+agents ignored them, but because nothing defined how to answer.
+
+This protocol closes that wiring gap without inventing a new system:
+- digest composer → `dm.py send --expect-reply` (followup record, timeout/nudges
+  declared at send time)
+- agent replies in-band with a verb: `[ACK|CLAIM|RESULT|DECLINE|NO-ACTION <id>]`
+- `response-harvester.py` matches by `job_id` and records the outcome in
+  `followups.json`
+- the sweeper nudges/escalates only unresolved followups, per the declared policy
+
+## 2. Digest classes
+
+Not every digest deserves a reply demand (notification fatigue; and the standing
+rule that the human only sees real decisions and escalations). The composer
+already marks `[?]` (question) and `[!]` (operator-needed / urgent).
+
+| Class | Marker | Response required? | Followup record? | Measured by |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| **ACTIONABLE** | carries `[?]` or `[!]` | **yes** | yes | delivered → acked → closed |
+| **INFORMATIONAL** | neither | no | no | delivered only |
+
+Informational digests are sent exactly as today. They are **excluded from every
+reply-rate metric** — an informational digest is measured as *delivered*, full stop.
+Judging informational FYI traffic by answer rate is structurally misleading.
+
+## 3. Digest ID
+
+Every ACTIONABLE digest gets a stable ID:
+
+```
+ml-<agent>-<YYYYMMDD-HHMMSS>
+```
+
+Example: `ml-646-20261004-213000`.
+
+The ID is embedded visibly in the digest as `[JOB ml-...]`. This marker survives
+`extract_trailing_tags` (only known canonical keys are stripped) and is picked up
+by `dm_send`'s job_id regex (`\[JOB\s+([A-Za-z0-9_-]+)\]`) anywhere in the message,
+so it lands in `tags["job_id"]` → the followup record. **No new dm.py flags are
+needed for the ID.**
+
+Replies match on this ID, so attribution games with `[from:X]` can never break
+resolution.
+
+## 4. Reply verbs
+
+Printed in the contract footer of every ACTIONABLE digest (Section 7).
+
+| Verb | Syntax | Meaning | Followup effect |
+|---|---|---|---|
+| `ACK` | `[ACK <id>]` | Seen, noted | status `acknowledged` — stops nudges, **not closed** |
+| `CLAIM` | `[CLAIM <id>]` | I'm handling it | status `acknowledged` — stops nudges, **not closed** |
+| `RESULT` | `[RESULT <id>] <result text>` | Done, result attached | status `resolved`, outcome `RESULT` — **closed** |
+| `DECLINE` | `[DECLINE <id>]` | Won't act (reason optional) | status `resolved`, outcome `DECLINE` — **closed** |
+| `NO-ACTION` | `[NO-ACTION <id>]` | Reviewed, nothing needed | status `resolved`, outcome `NO-ACTION` — **closed** |
+
+Semantics:
+- `ACK` vs `CLAIM`: both acknowledge. `CLAIM` signals ownership; `ACK` is just
+  "seen". Use `CLAIM` when you're picking up the work so the human knows who's on it.
+- `NO-ACTION` is a real answer, not a dodge. It means "I reviewed this and there
+  is genuinely nothing to do." It closes the digest so it stops being counted as open.
+- `DECLINE` should carry a reason when one exists (`[DECLINE ml-646-...] blocked:
+  chromebox flapping`), but a bare DECLINE is still a valid close.
+- `RESULT` closes only when the result text is present. An empty RESULT is a malformed
+  reply — the harvester treats it as unrecognized.
+
+Nudge interaction: `ACK`/`CLAIM` suppress further nudges but leave the followup open
+until a closing verb arrives. This matches the real workflow — "I'm on it" shouldn't
+trigger nags, but the loop isn't closed until there's a result.
+
+## 5. Timeout policy
+
+Declared at send time (standing rule: policy is part of the send, not decided later).
+
+| Digest class | Timeout | Nudges |
+|---|---|---|
+| normal (marked `[?]`) | 60 min | 2 |
+| urgent (marked `[!]`) | 30 min | 2 |
+
+Implemented as `--reply-timeout {3600|1800} --reply-nudges 2` on the `dm.py send`
+invocation for ACTIONABLE digests. The timeout and nudge count are stored in the
+followup record; the sweeper honors them.
+
+## 6. Nudge / escalation policy
+
+- The sweeper nudges only followups with `status == "pending"`. Anything
+  `acknowledged` or `resolved` is never re-nudged (ACKed digests getting nagged
+  trains agents to ignore the protocol — verify this when wiring the sweeper).
+- After the declared nudges are exhausted and the timeout passes, the followup is
+  **escalated**, not retried forever:
+  - **Phase 1:** the sweeper's existing escalation path (DM to the escalate target
+    declared at send time via `--reply-escalate`).
+  - **Phase 2:** route to the registered `main-loop brain` sidechat for triage.
+    The brain is registered in `job-sidechats.json` as `main-loop brain` and is
+    name-resolvable, so no hardcoded UUIDs are needed.
+- `stale` = still `pending` past timeout + nudges → escalated.
+
+Digest routing must use sidechat **names** (`646 tasks`, `main-loop brain`) via the
+existing name resolution — never hardcoded thread UUIDs (see the stale-UUID lesson
+in AGENTS.md).
+
+Note: the harvester only monitors threads registered in `job-sidechats.json`.
+`opm/heartbeat` is not registered (digests there resolve via fuzzy search), so
+digest replies there would never resolve. **Route opm's digests to the registered
+`main-loop brain` sidechat instead of `heartbeat`** — cleaner separation
+(brain = triage workspace, heartbeat = heartbeats) and zero new registrations.
+
+## 7. In-band contract footer
+
+The digest budget is 600 chars, so the footer is compact. Actionable digests trim
+message previews from 5 to 3 to fit it:
+
+```
+[main-loop] [JOB ml-646-20261004-213000] 3 new in 646 main chat — reply needed:
+- human: <preview> [?]
+Reply: [ACK id] seen | [CLAIM id] mine | [RESULT id] done | [DECLINE id] | [NO-ACTION id]
+```
+
+The footer is the primary contract. This doc is the reference.
+
+## 8. Example exchange
+
+```
+# opm → 646 tasks (ACTIONABLE, --expect-reply --reply-timeout 3600 --reply-nudges 2)
+
+[from:opm] [id:a6579a8d] [main-loop] [JOB ml-646-20261004-213000] 3 new in 646 main chat — reply needed:
+- human: should we archive the stale pipe-7d2896 thread? [?]
+- opm: propose yes, it's superseded by the brain channel [?]
+Reply: [ACK id] seen | [CLAIM id] mine | [RESULT id] done | [DECLINE id] | [NO-ACTION id]
+
+# 646 picks it up
+
+[from:646] [CLAIM ml-646-20261004-213000] reviewing now
+
+→ followup status: acknowledged (nudges suppressed, loop still open)
+
+# 646 finishes
+
+[from:646] [RESULT ml-646-20261004-213000] archived pipe-7d2896 via muse-cli; brain channel is canonical
+
+→ followup status: resolved, outcome: RESULT (loop closed)
+```
+
+A shorter close:
+
+```
+# pip sees an informational-with-a-question, reviews, nothing to do
+
+[from:pip] [NO-ACTION ml-pip-20261004-214500] reviewed — nothing needed, timer stagger already handles it
+
+→ followup status: resolved, outcome: NO-ACTION (loop closed)
+```
+
+## 9. Metrics
+
+Source of truth: `followups.json` (`outcome` field, written by the harvester).
+
+| Metric | Definition |
+|---|---|
+| **delivered** | `dm.py` reported `verified:true` with placement confirmed for the digest message (see dm-log) |
+| **acked** | outcome ∈ {`ACK`, `CLAIM`} |
+| **closed** | outcome ∈ {`RESULT`, `DECLINE`, `NO-ACTION`} |
+| **stale** | still `pending` past timeout + nudges → escalated |
+| **closure_rate** | `closed / actionable_delivered` |
+
+Rules:
+- Informational digests are excluded from every rate. They are measured as
+  delivered, full stop.
+- Actionable digests are measured as closed. A digest that is ACKed but never
+  resolved counts as open until a closing verb arrives.
+- `delivered` requires the placement confirmation, not just the `verified:true`
+  flag (see the AGENTS.md placement-blindness lesson).
+
+Reporting: `self_main_loop.py` `status` exposes `digest_health()` counts
+(delivered/acked/closed/stale), surfaced through the existing Box
+`main-loop/status` API. No new endpoint needed in phase 1.
+
+## 10. Implementation notes
+
+- `dm.py` — **no changes.** `--expect-reply`, job_id extraction from `[JOB …]`,
+  followup registration, and placement verification already exist and are tested.
+- `response-harvester.py` — extend the reply regex to verb-aware matching:
+  `\[(ACK|CLAIM|RESULT|DECLINE|NO-ACTION)\s+([A-Za-z0-9_-]+)\]`; on match, resolve
+  by job_id and record `outcome`. `ACK`/`CLAIM` → `acknowledged`;
+  `RESULT`/`DECLINE`/`NO-ACTION` → `resolved` + outcome.
+- `self_main_loop.py` — `compose_digest` classifies actionable vs informational;
+  actionable embeds `[JOB ml-…]` + footer; `send_prompt` passes
+  `--expect-reply --reply-timeout {3600|1800} --reply-nudges 2` for actionable only.
+- Sweeper — verify it nudges only `status == "pending"` (no code change expected).
+
+All changes follow review-then-commit. No new daemons, no new state files beyond
+the existing `followups.json`.
+
+---
+
+*Companion docs: `DM-SPEC.md` (DM format), `THREAD-BOOKKEEPING.md` (pin/archive),
+`WARP-EGRESS-FIX.md` (partition handling).*